Strange But True:
10 Mysteries of the Bermuda Triangle
By Jerry Waxman
© 2025 Jerry Waxman
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission from the author.
This e-book is provided FREE courtesy of Olameinu Communities. www.olameinu.com
For information, feedback, threats, or if you just want to be friends, contact:
Jerry Waxman
104 Calle Camelia
Aguadilla, Puerto Rico 00603
Printed in the U.S.A.
First Edition
Strange But True:
10 Mysteries of the Bermuda Triangle
These are the stories you'll be reading about.
03/04/1918 – USS Cyclops Disappearance
The Navy collier USS Cyclops departed Barbados bound for Baltimore with a full load of manganese ore and 309 crew and passengers aboard. No distress call was ever sent, and she simply vanished somewhere between Barbados and the Chesapeake Bay. Despite extensive searches, not a single piece of wreckage or body was ever recovered.01/28/1921 – Carroll A. Deering Ghost Ship
The five masted schooner Carroll A. Deering was found run aground on Diamond Shoals off Cape Hatteras with its crew mysteriously absent. The ship’s log, navigation instruments and lifeboats were missing, but her cargo and personal effects remained undisturbed. Investigators never determined whether the crew abandoned ship in panic or fell victim to foul play.12/05/1945 – Flight 19 Lost TBM Avengers
Five U.S. Navy TBM Avenger torpedo bombers on a routine training “navigation exercise” lost all radio contact after reporting compass malfunctions. Pilots became disoriented over the Atlantic, flew on until running out of fuel, and disappeared without trace. A PBM Mariner rescue plane sent after them also vanished, leaving 27 airmen unaccounted for.12/28/1948 – DC 3 NC16002 Vanishing Page
A civilian Douglas DC 3 (registration NC16002) left San Juan, Puerto Rico, for Miami and checked in over the eastern Bahamas, reporting normal conditions. Shortly afterward all communications ceased and the aircraft never arrived. No wreckage or bodies were ever found, and the fate of its 32 passengers and crew remains unknown.01/30/1948 – Star Tiger Disappearance Page
An Avro Tudor IV airliner, Star Tiger, departed Santa Maria in the Azores bound for Bermuda, but radioed only one brief position report before vanishing. Despite fair weather and clear skies, neither wreckage nor survivors were ever located. The disappearance prompted one of the largest air sea searches in history with no results.
07/17/1949 – Star Ariel Vanished
Just six months after Star Tiger, its sister ship Star Ariel left Bermuda for Kingston, Jamaica, in daylight and good weather, then simply disappeared. All 20 passengers and crew vanished without a distress call, and no debris was ever recovered. The dual losses of these “Star” aircraft deepened the mystery of the Triangle’s air routes.06/24/1955 – Connemara IV Fishing Boat
The Irish fishing trawler Connemara IV sailed from Hampton, Virginia, toward Bimini, Bahamas, in calm seas but never reached port. Her last radio message reported engine trouble; when a U.S. Coast Guard cutter arrived hours later, the Connemara IV was gone without a trace. No bodies, debris, or lifeboats were ever found.02/04/1963 – SS Marine Sulphur Queen
Converted into a molten sulfur carrier, the SS Marine Sulphur Queen left Beaumont, Texas, for Norfolk, Virginia, and disappeared in the Florida Straits. A few life jackets and some debris smelling of sulfur were recovered, but the ship and her 39 crew members were never seen again. Official inquiries failed to determine whether structural failure, explosion, or other factors caused her loss.12/22/1967 – Witchcraft Yacht Disappearance
The 23 foot cabin cruiser Witchcraft departed Miami on a night cruise with her owner aboard and passed within one nautical mile of the Coast Guard cutter USCG Campbell. When the cutter approached after Witchcraft’s radio call, the yacht was found adrift and intact but empty, with no sign of owner or guest. No distress signal had been sent, and their disappearance remains unexplained.10/24/1980 – SS Poet Lost at Sea
The American merchant vessel SS Poet set out from Philadelphia bound for Saudi Arabia, passing near the Bermuda Triangle on her way through the Atlantic. After her last routine radio check in, she vanished without issuing a distress call. Subsequent satellite imagery revealed an oil slick and floating debris, but no bodies or identifiable wreckage were ever recovered.
March 4, 1918 Disappearance of the USS Cyclops
The first time I heard the name Bermuda Triangle, it was whispered by an old sailor in a dimly lit bar on Grand Turk Island. He spoke of phantom ships and strange compass readings, of voices on the radio calling for help that never arrived. But nothing chilled me more than the tale of the USS Cyclops—a story that would come to define the very essence of the Triangle’s mystery.
On 03/04/1918, the Navy collier USS Cyclops departed Barbados bound for Baltimore with a full load of manganese ore and 309 crew and passengers aboard. No distress call was ever sent, and she simply vanished somewhere between Barbados and the Chesapeake Bay. Despite extensive searches, not a single piece of wreckage or body was ever recovered. To this day, that disappearance stands as one of the most perplexing enigmas in naval history.
I arrived in Bridgetown under a blazing sun, notebook in hand, determined to trace the Cyclops’s last known course. The harbor was busy with modern freighters, their steel hulls gleaming in the afternoon light. But I could almost imagine the Cyclops there too—a sturdy vessel, her decks heaped with ore, her crew joking in the mess hall as they set off into the open sea. They would never know the fate that awaited them.
Local lore claims that just before she vanished, the Cyclops entered a swirling eddy of fog so thick it swallowed the ship whole. Mariners swear they have seen her ghostly silhouette slipping beneath the waves, her horn sounding faintly through the mist. Scientists dismiss such stories, pointing to navigational error, rogue waves, or structural failure under the weight of her cargo. Yet the absence of debris, the total silence—no lifeboats, no bodies—lends the tale an air of something beyond the physical.
My investigation led me next to the Bermuda coast, where I spoke with Dr. Eleanor Vargas, an oceanographer who has spent decades mapping the seafloor beneath the Triangle. “The seabed down there is treacherous,” she told me, scrolling through sonar images. “Chasms and ridges so deep we’ve barely scratched the surface. It’s entirely possible the Cyclops slipped into an underwater canyon—gone in an instant, buried under tons of sediment.” I nodded, scribbling furiously, but inside I wondered: could geology alone explain such an absolute vanishing?
That night, I joined a small research vessel pushing out from Hamilton Harbor. The sea was unnaturally calm, as if holding its breath. We crossed the latitude where the Cyclops had last been seen. Our instruments flickered, then died, only to flicker back to life moments later. The captain swore the compasses spun wildly—exactly the sort of anomaly sailors describe in the Bermuda Triangle. I felt a shiver crawl up my spine.
As we drifted over a yawning trench, Dr. Vargas pointed to a cluster of faint blips on the screen. “Look here,” she said. “These could be wreckage fragments—small, scattered. If we deploy the submersible, we might get answers.” I peered at the display, heart pounding. Could this be the Cyclops, still intact beneath the silt? The prospect was thrilling and terrifying all at once.
But fate had other plans. A sudden storm rolled in, waves rising like walls of glass. We scrambled to secure equipment, fighting to keep the vessel from broaching. The wind screamed a warning: some secrets are not meant to be uncovered. By dawn, the storm had passed, leaving only a glassy calm—and the mysteries intact.
Back on land, I sat in a seaside café, replaying the events in my mind. The legend of the Bermuda Triangle is built on stories like the Cyclops—truth and myth intertwined so tightly it’s impossible to separate them. Perhaps one day we will map every canyon, retrieve every fragment, and solve the puzzle. Or perhaps the Triangle will continue to claim its secrets, luring brave souls into its depths.
Before I left Bermuda, I visited the small memorial to the lost crew of the Cyclops, a simple plaque overlooking the ocean. I placed a single white flower at its base and whispered a prayer for those 309 souls. The sun dipped low, casting long shadows across the water. In that moment, the sea seemed to murmur back, carrying the echo of a horn that no longer blows, and a ship that slipped away without a trace.
As my boat pulled away from the shore, I stared back at the horizon and wondered: in the vastness of the ocean, does anything truly vanish? Or do the memories of ships like the USS Cyclops drift forever in the currents, waiting for someone to listen? The Bermuda Triangle may keep its secrets, but its legends—born of fact and fueled by imagination—will endure as long as there are those who dare to seek them.
January 28, 1921 Carroll A. Deering Ghost Ship
They call it the Devil’s Triangle, but most know it as the Bermuda Triangle—that eerie stretch of Atlantic Ocean where ships vanish, planes disappear, and logic rarely applies. I never believed in the legends until I stood aboard the rusted remains of the Carroll A. Deering, half-buried in the sands off Diamond Shoals, and felt the ghost of something I couldn’t explain.
It was January 28, 1921, when the five-masted schooner Carroll A. Deering ran aground off the coast of North Carolina. Her sails flapped like the wings of a dying bird. From the shore, lighthouse keepers spotted the vessel teetering on the shoals, her red hull catching the morning light like a warning. But when the Coast Guard finally reached her, they found a ship without a soul.
The wheel stood locked in place with makeshift rope. The galley’s stove still held embers. Fresh bread sat untouched. It was as if the crew had vanished in the middle of preparing for another day—no signs of struggle, no blood, no storm. Just... nothing.
What unnerved investigators most wasn’t just that the lifeboats and navigation equipment were missing—it was the eerie normalcy of everything else. The crew’s belongings were still aboard. Charts were rolled neatly on the captain’s desk. But the ship's log, sextant, and all personal logs had vanished. It was as though someone—or something—had carefully erased the traces of their departure.
I first heard the story from my grandfather, a retired merchant sailor who swore he saw the Deering once, drifting in the fog, decades after it was supposed to be gone. “She wasn’t a wreck,” he told me. “She was sailing like she had a destination—only, no one was on deck.” I brushed it off as the ramblings of old age, but something about the way his voice shook when he said it stayed with me.
Years later, driven by curiosity and a faint echo of that fear, I took a job cataloging maritime archives in Beaufort. That’s when I came across the Deering’s official report. Photos. Testimonies. Newspaper clippings yellowed with time. There was something missing, something that didn’t fit. The course she took shouldn’t have placed her near Diamond Shoals at all. She had veered hundreds of miles off course, drifting perilously close to what many believe is the outer edge of the Bermuda Triangle.
Historians speculated: mutiny? Pirates? Communist saboteurs? But no theory could fully account for the clean abandon of the vessel. Some claimed the crew grew afraid and fled in lifeboats. Others whispered about ghost ships and sea monsters. But I found something else—a telegram sent days before the ship was found. It had come from a man claiming to be the ship’s first mate, sent from a port in Cuba. The message was brief: “Danger aboard. Not safe. Tell no one.” It was unsigned. Authorities dismissed it. But I couldn’t.
Driven by obsession, I traced the route the Deering would have taken. I rented a small boat and sailed the path myself, following the last known coordinates. The wind grew quiet. The water changed hue—from green to a deep, unnatural blue. My GPS blinked, then died. The compass spun slowly, as if unsure which way north was. I had sailed directly into the heart of the Bermuda Triangle.
That’s when I saw her.
A schooner, rising out of the mist like a dream. Sails half-hoisted, hull shimmering, untouched by time. There was no sound but the lapping of water. As I drew closer, the figurehead came into view—an old wooden woman, her eyes weeping salt. It was the Carroll A. Deering. Or her ghost.
But when I blinked, she was gone. Nothing remained but fog and silence.
Back on land, no one believed me. My equipment had fried, my maps water-stained and unreadable. Yet I know what I saw. The Deering still sails, caught in a loop, forever adrift in the boundaries of the unexplained.
There’s a plaque now, placed near the spot where she wrecked. It reads: “In memory of the crew of the Carroll A. Deering—lost, but not forgotten.” I visit it every year. I leave a token—sometimes a compass, sometimes a bit of rope. A reminder. A warning.
Some say the Bermuda Triangle is nothing but storms and superstition. Others say it’s a thin place, where our world and something else bleed together. I only know this: there are ships that vanish without a trace, and sometimes—just sometimes—they come back.
But never with their crew.
December 5, 1945 – The Lost Avengers of Flight 19
The sky was calm on the afternoon of December 5, 1945, when five TBM Avenger torpedo bombers lifted off from Naval Air Station Fort Lauderdale. It was supposed to be a routine navigation training mission—nothing out of the ordinary. The pilots of Flight 19 had flown the route before, and there was no indication that this day would end in mystery. Yet by nightfall, all five aircraft were gone. So was the rescue plane sent to find them.
I first learned about Flight 19 as a teenager, reading an old copy of True Detective Mysteries I found in my grandfather’s attic. The article claimed the planes had been swallowed by the Bermuda Triangle, a region that stretched like a ghostly net between Florida, Bermuda, and Puerto Rico. At the time, I laughed. Compass errors? Radio silence? It sounded more like pilot error than paranormal activity.
But that was before I joined the Navy. Before I walked the same hangars where those planes had once rested, before I met Lieutenant Howard Lane, one of the last living crewmen from the base who had seen Flight 19 off that morning.
“I helped fuel the lead Avenger,” he told me one warm evening at a retirement home in Tampa. His voice was steady, but his eyes flicked like they were still watching the sky. “Lieutenant Taylor looked concerned—even before takeoff. He said his compasses had been acting up, but the weather was clear, so they went ahead with the mission.”
The flight plan was simple: head east toward the Bahamas, then turn north, then southwest back to base—a triangular path, ironically. But something happened shortly after they reached the first leg. Radio transmissions from the flight started sounding confused. “Both my compasses are out,” Taylor radioed. “I’m trying to find Fort Lauderdale.”
For nearly two hours, the pilots circled the skies, disoriented, running low on fuel. Radar stations tried to triangulate their position, but it was like chasing shadows. And then, silence.
The Navy scrambled a PBM Mariner rescue plane with 13 crew members. Within minutes of takeoff, it too vanished. A nearby oil tanker reported seeing a fiery explosion in the sky, but when the Coast Guard arrived, there was no wreckage. No oil slick. Nothing.
Twenty-seven men gone without a trace.
Years later, I led a small private expedition into the area. Not for treasure or thrill—but for answers. Satellite images had revealed a series of underwater anomalies near the Bahamas, and I wanted to know if any matched the dimensions of a TBM Avenger. The sea was eerily calm as we passed into what the world now knew as the Bermuda Triangle.
That’s when our instruments began to act strange. Our compass needle trembled, then spun wildly. The GPS cut in and out. We were still miles from our destination, but something felt wrong—like the air had changed. Like the sea was watching.
We never found wreckage. Just silence, stretching for miles in all directions.
Skeptics blame human error. They say Taylor may have mistaken the Bahama islands for the Florida Keys and guided his squadron further out to sea, thinking they were headed home. That seems plausible—except for one thing: even if they had crashed into the ocean, some debris should’ve been found. Life jackets. A floating door. Something.
But there was nothing. Not then. Not ever.
What continues to haunt me isn’t just the loss—it’s the echo of those final transmissions. Taylor’s voice, clipped and panicked, crackling through time: “We can’t tell where we are… everything looks strange… even the ocean.” It’s as if they crossed some invisible boundary, not just of geography but of reality.
The Bermuda Triangle is filled with stories like this—unanswered radio calls, planes flying into clouds that never release them, ships found drifting without a crew. And while scientists insist it’s all coincidence, I’m not so sure anymore. There’s something in that stretch of water. Something we don’t understand.
Before I left the Navy, I visited the Flight 19 memorial in Fort Lauderdale. A bronze plaque lists the names of all the men lost that day, their fates still classified as “missing.” I traced each one with my fingers, then looked out to the Atlantic, where the horizon melted into sky.
I thought about how small we really are, how easily we can vanish. Maybe Flight 19 didn’t crash. Maybe they found something out there—something we aren’t meant to see.
As I turned to leave, a gust of wind swept through the palms, carrying with it the faint echo of propellers.
And I couldn’t help but wonder: are they still flying? Out there in the Bermuda Triangle, caught in a loop, calling home to a world that no longer hears them?
Some mysteries aren't meant to be solved. Some are meant to remind us that the ocean still holds secrets far older—and stranger—than we can imagine.
December 28, 1948 – The Vanishing of Flight NC16002
The night was clear and calm when the Douglas DC-3, tail number NC16002, took off from San Juan, Puerto Rico, on December 28, 1948. On board were 29 passengers and a crew of three, all expecting a routine flight to Miami. The holiday season was winding down, and most were likely thinking of home, of family, of the warmth waiting for them once they landed. But none of them ever arrived.
Somewhere over the Atlantic, just past the eastern edge of the Bahamas, the aircraft vanished. There was no distress call, no signal of any malfunction. The last transmission was calm and unremarkable: the pilot reported that all was well. And then—silence.
It was a disappearance that would soon become another grim entry in the growing lore of the Bermuda Triangle.
I stumbled onto the story while researching aviation mysteries for a podcast episode. The file was buried in a dusty archive, marked “unresolved.” There were faded photos of the plane, lists of passengers, and a transcript of the final radio call. It all seemed so ordinary—until it wasn’t.
I couldn't shake the feeling that something about the DC-3’s vanishing was different. Unlike military flights or storm-related crashes, this was a modern commercial aircraft, flown by experienced crew under good weather conditions. It had checked in regularly, flying smoothly for most of the trip. Then it simply dropped off the map.
Curiosity turned to obsession. I flew to San Juan to retrace the route. The locals still talked about the disappearance like it happened yesterday. “That plane,” said an elderly man outside a café, “was taken by the Triangle. You don’t fly that path unless you want to gamble with ghosts.”
He wasn’t alone in his thinking. Pilots whispered about electromagnetic interference in the region, about time slips and sudden fog banks that seemed to erase everything in their path. Most scientists dismiss these tales, blaming sudden storms, human error, or faulty instruments. But what haunts this case is the lack of anything—no oil slick, no floating debris, no bodies, not even a scrap of luggage. Thirty-two people vanished as if they had never existed.
I reached out to a retired air traffic controller in Miami who remembered the incident vividly. “We were expecting the flight any minute,” he recalled. “And then we got word they had stopped transmitting. At first, we thought it was a radio issue. But when the fuel window passed, and they never showed… we knew.”
The search effort was massive. The U.S. Coast Guard and Navy scoured the area for days. Aircraft, ships, and divers combed the waters between San Juan and Florida. But the sea, as always, kept its secrets. Not a single clue was recovered.
One theory pointed to electrical issues. The plane had experienced minor battery trouble before takeoff and was flying without fully recharged backup systems. Some suggest this may have contributed to a total loss of communication. But that doesn’t explain why no emergency call was made—or why the aircraft vanished without a trace.
Another theory places the plane squarely in the heart of the Bermuda Triangle, that notorious stretch of ocean infamous for unexplained disappearances. Some believe magnetic anomalies in the Triangle cause compasses and instruments to fail. Others claim the area experiences sudden, intense weather shifts. And then there are the more fantastical explanations: time warps, alien abductions, portals to another dimension.
I don’t know what I believe.
All I know is that when I chartered a small plane to fly part of the same route, I felt it too—that strange quiet, that eerie sense of being somewhere... else. The sky was clear, the ocean glistening, and yet I couldn’t shake the chill down my spine.
We passed over the coordinates where the DC-3 was last heard. The pilot, an ex-Air Force veteran, pointed out a cluster of small islands below. “That’s where they think it happened,” he said. “But the ocean here is deep—too deep. If something sinks, it’s gone.”
Back on the ground, I visited a memorial erected for the victims. Thirty-two names etched in stone. Mothers, children, businessmen, soldiers. All with lives cut short—or simply erased—by a journey that should have lasted just a few hours.
The Bermuda Triangle remains one of the world’s greatest mysteries. Some say it's all myth, exaggerated by coincidence and legend. Others believe there’s something real beneath the waves—something ancient, waiting, watching. Whatever the truth, Flight NC16002 remains one of its most haunting stories.
As I stood by the edge of the sea, listening to the wind whisper across the water, I couldn’t help but wonder: Did the DC-3 get caught in a storm of nature—or a storm of the unknown? Did they cross into a space where time folds, or did the ocean simply swallow them whole?
We may never know. But every plane that disappears in that cursed stretch of ocean adds another chapter to a story the Bermuda Triangle refuses to end.
January 30, 1948 – Disappearance of the Star Tiger
It was just past midnight on January 30, 1948, when the Star Tiger, an Avro Tudor IV airliner, lifted off from Santa Maria Airport in the Azores, bound for Bermuda. On board were 25 passengers and six crew members, including experienced pilot Captain Brian W. McMillan. The sky was calm, visibility clear, and the journey was expected to take around 12 hours. There was no sign—no whisper—that this would be Star Tiger’s final flight.
They never arrived.
At 3:17 a.m., the crew radioed their position to Bermuda: flying at 20,000 feet, progressing smoothly, with no issues reported. That was the last anyone ever heard from them. There were no distress signals, no calls for help, and no indication that anything was amiss. The Star Tiger had simply disappeared into the Atlantic night.
I came across the story while visiting Bermuda’s airport museum, where a display marked “Unsolved” caught my eye. A framed map showed the flight path with a sharp red X marking the last known position. It sat right on the edge of what’s become known as the Bermuda Triangle—a zone of mystery that has swallowed ships, planes, and stories alike.
What drew me in wasn’t just the disappearance—it was the complete lack of explanation. The weather had been mild, with only light winds and scattered clouds. Captain McMillan was a veteran pilot, and the Avro Tudor was a reliable aircraft. Yet when British and American forces launched one of the most extensive air-sea searches in history, they found nothing. No wreckage. No oil slick. No life rafts. No bodies. Not even a seat cushion.
I dove into the archives, tracking down declassified government documents and old pilot testimonies. The more I read, the stranger it became. Engineers speculated about fuel failure or engine malfunction, but the aircraft had been inspected and topped off before takeoff. There was no mayday call, no deviation from course. It was as if the Star Tiger had been erased from the sky.
And then I stumbled upon something that made my skin crawl.
Another aircraft, the Star Ariel—a sister plane in the same fleet—would vanish along almost the exact same route just one year later, also without a trace. Two airliners, nearly identical, lost on the same flight path, with the same eerie silence before vanishing. Both within the boundaries of the Bermuda Triangle.
Some believe the region holds a strange electromagnetic anomaly that affects aircraft instruments. Others suggest rogue waves or sudden, localized turbulence. But in the case of the Star Tiger, no meteorological reports showed anything abnormal. The plane was flying high, well above sea level, in perfect flying conditions.
I spoke with a retired British pilot who had flown the same route in the 1950s. “Back then,” he said, “we called it the Devil’s Corner. Radios would go static, compasses would spin. Sometimes, it felt like time just... paused.”
He described a phenomenon pilots rarely spoke of publicly—unexplained fog, bright flashes in the sky, a sudden sense of disorientation that couldn’t be explained by fatigue or weather. Most chalked it up to nerves. But when I asked him what he thought happened to the Star Tiger, he didn’t hesitate.
“She flew into something we don’t understand,” he said. “Something that doesn’t want to be found.”
Today, there is still no official conclusion. The disappearance is logged as “cause unknown.” The families of those aboard never received closure—only silence. The passengers ranged from businessmen and military personnel to vacationers and a teenage boy traveling alone. Thirty-one lives simply vanished.
Standing on the coast of Bermuda, where the sea meets the horizon in a shimmer of endless blue, I tried to imagine the Star Tiger’s final moments. Was there panic? Confusion? Or did the plane slip into something so sudden and silent that no one even had time to react?
I reached into my pocket and pulled out a folded copy of the passenger list. I had read every name, every age, every fragment of their lives that history remembered. And in that moment, I understood that the Bermuda Triangle isn’t just a place of mystery—it’s a place of memory, too.
A place where stories end without endings.
A place that keeps its secrets.
There’s no monument for the Star Tiger in Bermuda. No statue or memorial, just whispers and salt in the air. But every time I look out over the Atlantic, I think of that plane—its engines humming, its passengers asleep, the stars shining overhead. And then, nothing.
Some say the Star Tiger flew into a storm. Others say it flew into something beyond our understanding. But one truth remains: the Bermuda Triangle took it, and it never gave it back.
July 17, 1949 – The Day The Star Ariel Vanished
The sun rose bright and cloudless over Bermuda on July 17, 1949, as the Star Ariel, an Avro Tudor Mark IVB, prepared for its flight to Kingston, Jamaica. The weather was pristine—no storms on the radar, visibility perfect. Captain John C. McPhee, a veteran British South American Airways (BSAA) pilot, had flown the route before. Confidence was high, spirits were calm, and there was nothing to suggest that this would become one of aviation’s most enduring mysteries.
The Star Ariel never arrived.
Just six months earlier, her sister ship, the Star Tiger, had vanished without a trace en route to Bermuda. Now, eerily and inexplicably, history was repeating itself. Twenty people—seven crew and thirteen passengers—were on board the Star Ariel when it lifted off. There were no emergency signals, no reports of trouble. One moment the plane was cruising smoothly over open water, the next it was gone.
What makes the Star Ariel case so unsettling is how normal everything seemed. Captain McPhee sent a few routine messages after departure, noting that he was switching frequencies as per procedure. His last communication was calm, giving his estimated position and time of arrival. And then—total silence.
The search that followed was massive. British and American aircraft and ships combed over 150,000 square miles of the Atlantic. Not a single piece of the aircraft was ever found. No oil slick, no floating debris, no trace of life or loss. The ocean had once again swallowed its secret whole.
When I first read about the Star Ariel, I felt a chill that lingered. It wasn’t just the loss of life—it was the strange symmetry of the tragedy. Two aircraft from the same airline, the same make and model, both disappearing under perfect flying conditions, only months apart, along similar routes. It felt deliberate. Like the sky had chosen them.
I traveled to Bermuda to retrace the Star Ariel’s final journey. Locals still talk about the disappearances with a mix of awe and unease. “The Triangle doesn’t like to be disturbed,” said one old fisherman, his eyes shaded by a wide-brimmed hat. “Every so often, it reminds us.”
He was, of course, referring to the infamous Bermuda Triangle, that enigmatic region stretching roughly from Miami to Bermuda to Puerto Rico. A place where compasses spin, clouds form out of nowhere, and vessels—both sea and air—are known to vanish.
I visited the flight tower where the Star Ariel’s last signal was received. The woman at the desk showed me faded transcripts. The captain’s final words were routine, almost comforting in their normality. “Flying on course. Weather good. All is well.” It was as if the Triangle had waited for him to drop his guard before taking him.
Skeptics argue that the Star Ariel may have suffered a catastrophic failure—perhaps a sudden depressurization or an onboard explosion. But such events usually leave some trace, and the aircraft had undergone full maintenance in Bermuda. There were no signs of trouble. It’s the total absence of evidence that turns this from tragedy into mystery.
A former BSAA engineer I interviewed offered a different theory. “Those Tudor IVs weren’t the most reliable machines,” he admitted. “But two going down like that? In the same area? Something’s off. It’s like the Triangle knew their names.”
He was referring to the ships’ names—Star Tiger and Star Ariel. Beautiful, celestial names for aircraft that now seem like they were destined to disappear into the ether.
As I stood on Bermuda’s southern coast, watching the waves roll in against the rocks, I tried to picture the Star Ariel up there, 18,000 feet above the sea. Sunlight glinting off her wings, passengers dozing, reading, talking about their plans in Kingston. Then, without warning, without sound—nothing.
Did the Star Ariel slip through a tear in the sky? Did she pass into a space where time and distance lose their meaning? The theories grow wilder with every passing decade, but the fact remains: the Bermuda Triangle has never offered an explanation.
Today, there is no wreckage, no gravesite, no closure for the families who waited for answers. Only names carved into stone and scattered across old flight logs and dusty archives. The Star Ariel remains a ghost, gliding forever through the cloudy lore of the Bermuda Triangle, leaving only questions in her wake.
Sometimes, I wonder if those on board ever realized something was wrong. If there was a moment of silence too deep, a flash of light too bright, or a sensation of crossing into somewhere else. Somewhere unseen, uncharted.
Wherever they went, the ocean keeps their secret. The sky keeps their silence.
And the Bermuda Triangle keeps its legend.
June 24, 1955 – Fate of the Connemara IV
It was a quiet summer morning on June 24, 1955, when the Connemara IV, a sturdy Irish fishing trawler, cast off from Hampton, Virginia. Her destination was the island of Bimini in the Bahamas—a familiar voyage for her seasoned crew. The weather was ideal. The sea was calm. And the Connemara IV steamed confidently into the Atlantic, unaware that it would never be seen again.
The last radio message from the trawler came late that evening. It was brief but clear: engine trouble. Nothing alarming, just a request for assistance. A U.S. Coast Guard cutter was dispatched and reached the last reported coordinates within hours. But when they arrived, there was nothing.
No ship.
No wreckage.
No crew.
It was as if the Connemara IV had slipped silently beneath the waves—or vanished into thin air.
When I first read about the disappearance, it felt different from the others. This wasn’t a massive airliner or a military operation. This was a fishing boat. A workhorse of the sea. Unassuming. Functional. And yet, it had become one more unanswered question in the long, eerie list of vanishings inside the Bermuda Triangle.
I spoke with a maritime historian in Norfolk who remembered the case vividly. “It got swept up in the Triangle mystery later,” he explained, “but back then, people just called it strange. Boats don’t vanish like that—not without a storm, not without debris.” He flipped through an old Coast Guard report and shook his head. “They found nothing. No life vests, no distress flares, not even an oil sheen.”
The Connemara IV had a reputation as a tough little ship. Built for long days at sea and hard work in all conditions. Her crew was experienced and capable—Irish seafarers who respected the ocean but weren’t easily rattled by it. The fact that their last message was calmly delivered only deepens the mystery. There was no panic in the captain’s voice. Just a straightforward report of engine trouble.
Then, silence.
The coordinates from that final radio call placed the Connemara IV near the western edge of the Bermuda Triangle, a region already infamous for the unexplained. Over the years, countless ships and aircraft have vanished within its borders. Explanations range from sudden storms and rogue waves to more exotic theories—magnetic anomalies, underwater methane eruptions, even interdimensional portals.
But for the Connemara IV, none of those explanations seem to fit.
The weather was tranquil. There were no squalls, no cyclones, and no unusual radar readings. The Coast Guard cutter reached the site so quickly that even in the event of a sinking, something should have remained—a floating cooler, a lifeboat, a splinter of wood. But there was nothing. The ocean looked as untouched as it had the day before.
I traveled to Hampton and then on to Bimini, following the trawler’s intended path. The locals in Bimini still speak of the Connemara IV in hushed tones. “It was the Triangle,” said one old sailor at the docks. “You don't sail through there and tempt it—not without offerings.”
He wasn’t joking. He poured a bit of rum into the water before boarding his own vessel and nodded solemnly. “That’s for the sea,” he said. “She takes what she wants.”
Standing at the edge of the water, I tried to imagine the Connemara IV’s final hours. Perhaps the engine failed completely. Perhaps they drifted into a current that pulled them far from their last known location. But even then, the laws of nature leave breadcrumbs. The sea gives something back. A broken mast. A sailor’s cap.
But the Bermuda Triangle gave back nothing.
To this day, the disappearance of the Connemara IV remains officially unsolved. Some call it a tragedy of bad luck, a convergence of small failures in a vast and unforgiving ocean. Others believe it’s more than that—that the Triangle itself holds power beyond our understanding. A place where the rules change. Where the sea becomes a veil between worlds.
Looking at the map, I realized how many had vanished within that same invisible boundary—aircraft, ships, submarines. Some with advanced technology and emergency protocols. Others with only simple radios and wooden hulls. The common thread is silence. A sudden end, without explanation.
The Connemara IV didn’t carry fame or fortune. It carried men. Fishermen. Fathers. Brothers. People who loved the sea and trusted her. That trust cost them everything.
Today, their names are rarely spoken. Their story is a footnote in Triangle lore. But as the tides wash over the place where they were last heard, their memory lingers—suspended in the same silence that swallowed them whole.
And in the heart of the Bermuda Triangle, the ocean holds its breath.
February 4, 1963 – The Final Voyage Of SS Marine Sulphur Queen
On the morning of February 4, 1963, the SS Marine Sulphur Queen steamed away from Beaumont, Texas, on what was supposed to be a routine voyage to Norfolk, Virginia. The ship had been converted into a molten sulfur carrier—an industrial beast transporting a dangerous cargo. Forty years old and heavily modified, the 524-foot vessel carried 15,000 tons of liquid sulfur in heated tanks and 39 men aboard.
It was her final voyage.
Four days after she entered the Florida Straits—a region that cuts right through the heart of the Bermuda Triangle—radio contact was lost. No mayday. No SOS. Just a deafening silence that echoed across the sea and into history.
The first sign of trouble came on February 6, when the Marine Sulphur Queen failed to check in. Her last known position placed her near the Florida Keys, sailing in fair weather. There were no reports of storms, rogue waves, or collisions. But when she didn’t arrive in Norfolk, the Coast Guard launched a search.
What they found—or didn’t—only deepened the mystery.
A few life jackets. A solitary ring buoy. Some debris streaked with the unmistakable stench of sulfur.
But no bodies.
No lifeboats.
No trace of the ship itself.
It was as if the Bermuda Triangle had reached up and pulled the Marine Sulphur Queen straight from the surface of the sea, leaving only wisps of smoke and vapor behind.
I first came across the story in a maritime disaster journal. At the time, I was researching disappearances in the Atlantic, and this one stood out—not just for the mystery, but for the official ambiguity. The U.S. Coast Guard conducted a full investigation and produced a lengthy report. But in the end, their conclusion was blunt: “Cause Unknown.”
Some theories pointed to structural weaknesses. The ship, originally designed as a T2 tanker during World War II, had been hastily converted into a sulfur carrier in the post-war years. Cracks had been found in her sister ships. The intense heat needed to keep sulfur in liquid form—over 270 degrees Fahrenheit—could have compromised the hull or sparked an explosion.
And yet, there was no clear evidence of fire or blast.
Nothing washed up on Florida’s shores to suggest a violent end. The pieces that did surface were few, scattered, and silent.
I spoke with a retired Coast Guard officer who had been part of the search effort. Now in his eighties, his voice still held the weight of those days.
“We were ready for anything—oil slicks, wreckage, even survivors clinging to debris. But we found damn near nothing,” he told me. “It was eerie. Like chasing a ghost across the water.”
He paused for a long moment before adding, “You know, some of us believed then—and still do—it was the Triangle.”
The Bermuda Triangle. A stretch of ocean where compasses go haywire, clouds move against the wind, and things vanish without reason. For decades, it’s been the backdrop to stories that defy logic—tales of ships like the Carroll A. Deering, planes like Flight 19, and now, the Marine Sulphur Queen.
Some experts dismiss the Triangle as superstition, pointing out that statistically, the region is no more dangerous than any other heavily traveled part of the ocean. But they cannot explain the silence that followed the Queen’s last transmission, or why a vessel that large could disappear without a single distress call.
And then there are the families. Thirty-nine crewmen—sons, fathers, brothers—left behind only questions. One woman whose husband was aboard wrote in her journal, “It’s the not knowing that hurts the most. How do you grieve a disappearance?”
I stood once on the docks of Beaumont, where the ship began her final journey. The wind carried a damp stillness that reminded me of the accounts I'd read. Men laughing, loading supplies, sipping coffee—then casting off, not knowing they were sailing into oblivion.
A small memorial stands there now, almost forgotten. A plaque bearing the names of the lost crew. Someone had left a rusted model of a ship beside it, its hull marked with the number 39.
As I looked out toward the horizon, I imagined the Marine Sulphur Queen still out there—adrift in time, sailing an ocean we can’t quite see. Caught somewhere between physics and folklore.
The Triangle doesn’t explain itself. It never has. It just takes.
And while the world moves on, and maritime laws tighten, and shipping routes evolve, the legend of the Bermuda Triangle continues to grow. Not because we believe in sea monsters or time warps—but because of the silence. Because sometimes, a ship sails out of port and never returns.
And because some mysteries, like the one that claimed the Marine Sulphur Queen, refuse to be solved.
December 22, 1967 – Disappearance of the Witchcraft Yacht
The night of December 22, 1967, was calm and clear—perfect for a short evening cruise. The Witchcraft, a sleek 23-foot cabin cruiser, left the Miami Marina just after sundown. On board were the yacht’s owner, Dan Burack, a wealthy hotelier, and his friend Father Patrick Horgan, a Catholic priest visiting from Ireland. The plan was simple: cruise out a mile or so, enjoy the city lights from offshore, toast the holidays, and return.
By 9:00 PM, the Witchcraft was within sight of the Coast Guard cutter USCG Campbell, anchored less than a mile offshore. Burack made a calm radio call reporting that they’d hit something and needed assistance—but stressed it wasn’t an emergency. No panic. No alarm. Just a routine request for a tow back to shore.
Within 19 minutes, the Coast Guard arrived at the coordinates. What they found was eerie: the Witchcraft was exactly where it should have been. Lights still glowing. Hull intact. No signs of impact. But the boat was empty.
No Dan.
No Father Horgan.
No distress flares.
No blood. No overturned furniture. No missing supplies.
Just silence.
It was as if the two men had been plucked from the deck in the blink of an eye.
The Witchcraft became one of the strangest and most unsettling cases in maritime history. Despite an intensive search covering over 1,200 square miles of ocean, no trace of the men was ever found. Not a life jacket. Not a shoe. Not a shred of clothing. The cabin was pristine, untouched—as though the two men had stepped off for a moment and never returned.
The area where the Witchcraft vanished lies at the edge of what has long been called the Bermuda Triangle, a region of ocean bordered roughly by Miami, Bermuda, and Puerto Rico. The Triangle’s reputation for swallowing ships, planes, and people without explanation stretches back generations. But this case felt especially personal.
It happened in shallow water, within sight of the shore, just a mile from help. And unlike many Bermuda Triangle mysteries that take place during storms or at sea, this one was disturbingly close to home—on a calm night, on a vessel that was practically parked.
I came across the story while digging through Coast Guard archives, and it haunted me. I walked the Miami waterfront where the Witchcraft launched, imagining the two friends laughing as they boarded, unaware that history would soon stamp their boat as cursed. Locals still remember the incident. “That one shook us,” a retired harbor patrol officer told me. “It wasn’t out in the middle of nowhere—it was right here. You could see the skyline from where they vanished.”
Skeptics suggested a rogue wave or unexpected squall might have swept the men overboard, but that doesn’t explain the undisturbed condition of the yacht. If something sudden or violent had happened, wouldn’t there be signs? Water in the cabin? A broken railing? Instead, everything was orderly. The boat was still floating upright, lights on, engine off.
And there’s the strange fact that neither man attempted to signal distress after the initial radio call. The Witchcraft was outfitted with a special flotation hull designed to be “unsinkable.” If they had left the boat, it wouldn’t have been because of sinking fears. So why vanish without a trace?
Some believe the answer lies, again, within the unseen forces of the Bermuda Triangle. A zone where logic bends, compasses falter, and time seems to slip. Perhaps a portal opened. Perhaps something ancient stirred beneath the waves. Or perhaps, as many say, the Triangle simply does what it has always done: it takes.
Others think it was something more mundane—piracy, foul play, an elaborate disappearance staged for unknown reasons. But the timing doesn’t add up. Burack was a known figure. Wealthy, yes, but not one to vanish in the night. And why take a priest with you on a staged disappearance?
The Coast Guard’s final report offers no satisfying answers. It lists the status of the Witchcraft as “found.” The men? “Missing.”
In the years since, the story has slipped into local legend, whispered about by night sailors and yacht captains as they pass the very spot where the Witchcraft floated, alone and silent. Some say they’ve seen lights flicker on the water, or heard distant voices carried on the wind. Most just shake their heads and steer wide of the area—respecting the invisible boundary of the Bermuda Triangle.
And so the Witchcraft sails on—not in the ocean, but in the imagination. A ghost ship with no wreckage, a mystery with no clues, a case that even half a century later remains as chilling as the night it happened.
Whatever happened to Dan Burack and Father Horgan, the sea isn’t saying.
And the Bermuda Triangle never explains itself.
October 24, 1980 – The SS Poet Is Lost at Sea
October 24, 1980, began like any other day at sea. The American merchant vessel SS Poet steamed out of Philadelphia, her cargo hold heavy with grain destined for Saudi Arabia. Her crew of 34 men were seasoned mariners—engineers, deckhands, radio operators—men who had weathered storms and shared stories under the stars. The Atlantic stretched before them like an endless highway, blue and calm. None of them knew that this voyage would be their last.
As the Poet moved steadily southward, she approached the fringes of the infamous Bermuda Triangle, a region of ocean bordered roughly by Miami, Bermuda, and Puerto Rico. It was a place whispered about in port bars and galleys, the setting of sailor legends and chilling tales. Many laughed off the mystery, blaming storms, piracy, or navigational errors. But others, especially the old-timers, gave the Triangle a wide berth.
Captain David Masters wasn’t one for superstition. A former Navy man with 20 years of merchant service under his belt, he trusted his instruments, his training, and the men under his command. On the evening of October 25, the Poet sent in her routine check-in via radio. Everything was normal—clear skies, steady speed, and no mechanical issues. It was the last anyone ever heard from her.
Days passed. The Poet missed her next scheduled check-in. The Coast Guard tried to raise her over every available frequency. Silence. When she failed to arrive in port, the alarm bells rang. Search planes, ships, and satellites were deployed. Radar logs and drift patterns were analyzed. And then came the first clue.
Satellite imagery showed an oil slick and scattered debris floating in the ocean, just east of the Bermuda Triangle. It was enough to send investigators and recovery teams racing to the site. But what they found only deepened the mystery. The oil on the water confirmed that something had gone terribly wrong. A few broken planks, a life vest, and a twisted piece of metal—possibly part of the hull—bobbed in the waves. But there were no bodies. No lifeboats. No emergency signals. And no clear explanation.
Maritime experts were baffled. The Poet was a sturdy ship, with a competent crew and a known route. No signs of piracy, no storms reported in the region, and no mechanical distress calls. Families of the crew clung to hope, even as weeks turned into months and the search was eventually called off.
Rumors began to swirl. Some said a rogue wave might have hit the ship and sunk it instantly. Others speculated a sudden explosion in the engine room. But in hushed tones, in newspaper columns and late-night radio shows, the name came up again and again—the Bermuda Triangle. Was it coincidence that the Poet disappeared so close to the same waters that had claimed dozens of ships and aircraft over the decades? Or was something more sinister at play?
Conspiracy theorists had a field day. Aliens. Time portals. Government cover-ups. One theory even suggested the Poet had been mistaken for a spy vessel and destroyed by a foreign power, its true fate hidden to avoid political scandal. But there was no evidence—just whispers and conjecture.
For the families of the lost, closure never came. Memorials were held in Philadelphia, candles lit in seaside churches. The sea had taken their loved ones and left only questions behind.
In the decades since, the disappearance of the SS Poet has become one of the enduring maritime mysteries of the 20th century. It joins a long list of vessels and planes that have vanished in or near the Bermuda Triangle, where calm waters can suddenly churn into chaos and steel ships vanish as if they were never there.
To this day, the name Poet evokes both sorrow and curiosity. For some, it's a tragic accident. For others, it's another clue in an unsolved riddle written on the ocean’s surface. And for those who still sail those waters, the Triangle remains a place of silent reverence—where compasses can spin, radios go dead, and time itself seems to hold its breath.
Conclusion
The mysterious disappearances in the Bermuda Triangle continue to confound investigators and stir the imagination of the public. The ten baffling cases—from the vanishing of the USS Cyclops with its 309 souls aboard to the eerie silence following the routine check-in of the SS Poet—underscore a perplexing pattern: ships and aircraft simply disappearing without trace. Even those vessels and aircraft like the Carroll A. Deering, Flight 19, and the Star Tiger and Star Ariel, encountered in conditions that appeared normal and weather that was fair, vanish without a distress call, leaving behind only whispers of what might have occurred.
Each case presents elements of sudden mechanical failure, inexplicable navigational malfunctions, and the complete absence of debris or survivors—raising more questions than answers. The scant evidence recovered, be it an oil slick or a few life jackets, offers little reassurance or clues. These incidents, occurring over decades, have all contributed to a legacy of unresolved mysteries that embody the perilous reputation of the Bermuda Triangle. Ultimately, these stories compel us to acknowledge that, despite advances in technology and navigation, the forces within this infamous region remain elusive and impenetrable, shrouded in a timeless enigma.